Advertisement

What are the demerits of Mendeleev's Periodic table?

1.                   Hydrogen was placed in group 1 and in group 17 as it resembles alkali metals as well as halogens. Therefore, no fixed position could be given to hydrogen in Mendeleev’s periodic table.

2.                   Though isotopes of the same elements have different atomic masses, they cannot be placed separately in the periodic table. Since isotopes are chemically similar, they had to be given the same position in the periodic table.

3.                   Some elements with higher atomic masses are placed before those having lower atomic masses, e.g. cobalt with atomic mass 58.93 is placed before nickel having atomic mass 58.71.


4.                   Dissimilar elements were placed in the same group. E.g. Mn (Manganese) was placed in the group of halogens which totally differ in the properties.